The 1960s: Watch This Penalty from Plymouth v Manchester City!

On this day (21 November) in 1964 Manchester City travelled away to Plymouth Argyle. The Blues lost 3-2 but you really need to take a look at this penalty captured on film that day. Malcolm Allison (seen here at my Joe Mercer book launch in 1993) was the Plymouth manager back then, so I guess he had a hand in the plan:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2iuw4NBYCI

You can read more on Malcolm Allison (and listen to an interview I did with him), Plymouth and on Manchester City in the 1960s across this website. Why not sta, here’s a subscriber article on Manchester City during the 1964-65 season. This was a remarkable season when a City director held meetings, hoping to merge City and United! Plus much more. If you’d like to read this 2350 word article, plus all other articles on the site, then please subscribe (see below). As with most of the other features in this series it includes words from interviews I have performed with those who were there.

Subscribe to get access

Read more of this content when you subscribe today. It costs £3 per month (cancel anytime) or sign up for a year at the discounted price of £20 per year (works out £1.67 per month). Subscribers access the 1000+ articles posted so far and the others scheduled during the life of your subscription.

Manchester 1840-1919 (Part Eleven)

Here’s another subscriber post from my book ‘The Emergence of Footballing Cultures: Manchester 1840-1919’. It tells the story of men’s football in Manchester and today’s section is the tenth chapter of the book (a 7,400 word section). This is another topical one as it focuses on a Manchester footballing scandal, namely United’s match fixing scandal. Fans of both Manchester’s League teams should find something in it for them while those not familiar with the scandal at United will be able to read the facts, not the fiction.

Subscribing costs £3 per month (cancel anytime) or you could sign up for a year at the discounted price of £20 per year. Every subscriber gets access to everything posted on the site.

Subscribe to get access

Read more of this content when you subscribe today.

Manchester Corinthians 2nd Edition Cover

Here’s the draft cover for the latest edition of Manchester Corinthians: The Authorised History. The book’s at the designer and we’ve colourised the early image on the cover to show the 1940s players in their original kit colours. The new edition of the book includes a few extra stories from players who have come forward from the opening years in the 1940s and also some players from the 1950s. The quest to find other Corinthians remains. More on the book here:

If you missed it earlier this month I posted the following about my 11-year project into the history of women’s football in Greater Manchester.

When I began this project in 2015, there was no comprehensive, documented history of Manchester City’s early women’s team, nor of the pioneering Manchester Corinthians—two important teams that won leagues and competitions long before the establishment of the WSL. For years, many of the women who played for these teams felt excluded. Every time historians or the media repeated inaccurate assumptions, it felt as though those who played their part in building the foundations of the game were being deliberately erased from memory.

Over the past decade, this project has worked to change that by capturing the vital stories of players from the Corinthians, Nomads, All Stars, Dynamos, City, United, and beyond. The scale of this research includes:

• Over 50 personal interviews with Manchester Corinthians players alone.
• Approximately 90 interviews and chats with female players, spanning from the 1940s to recent icons like Jill Scott.
• Uncovering multiple founding Corinthians from the original 1948 squad.
• Unearthing a vibrant 1950s community of women’s football clubs spanning the north, south, west and east of the conurbation (complemented by Steve Bolton’s valuable research into Manchester Ladies).

I am incredibly proud that this research has brought these narratives into the public consciousness. The history of women’s football in Manchester is vastly better known today than it was eleven years ago.

However, there is still work to be done. Despite a decade of progress, historical misconceptions and origin myths continue to be repeated. As a passionate advocate for the Corinthians and their sister clubs, my goal is always to protect their legacy by focusing strictly on facts.

The biggest misconception is the claim that no other women’s teams existed in Manchester when the Corinthians were established. The facts tell a different story: the Corinthians were not the first post-WWII women’s team in the city, nor were they the only local side to tour abroad in the 1950s. Similarly, the role of these clubs in challenging the FA ban and establishing international, national, and regional competitions is still too often overlooked in mainstream spaces.

Correcting these narratives remains a priority through my ongoing books, talks, and lectures. Recently, this has continued down exciting avenues, including filming with UEFA, discussing theatrical projects for the stage, and holding serious developmental conversations with Manchester’s leading men’s clubs.

Looking back on the last eleven years, the journey has been profoundly rewarding. From creating the Corinthians’ blue plaque appeal and organising player reunions, to preserving the heritage of the early City Ladies, it has been an honour. Most of all, it has been a distinct pleasure to meet and engage with pioneering women across Europe, North America, and Australia who proudly played football in Manchester.

We have come a long way, but the storytelling continues. Watch this space!

Manchester 1840-1919 (Part Ten)

I’ve missed a few weeks, but today we’re restarting the series of subscriber posts from my book ‘The Emergence of Footballing Cultures: Manchester 1840-1919’. It tells the story of men’s football in Manchester and today’s section is the ninth chapter of the book (a 9,000 word section). This may be quite topical in that it focuses on City’s illegal payments scandal (United’s match fixing scandal comes next week!) and on the building of Old Trafford. It also covers the shock departure of Ernest Mangnall from the Reds to the Blues. Fans of both Manchester’s League teams should find something in it for them while those not familiar with the scandal at City will be able to read the facts, not the fiction.

Subscribing costs £3 per month (cancel anytime) or you could sign up for a year at the discounted price of £20 per year. Every subscriber gets access to everything posted on the site.

Subscribe to get access

Read more of this content when you subscribe today.

Guest Blog: No Money, No Team: The Rise and Fall of Stalybridge Rovers

In the week when the musician Stevie Wonder turned up in Stalybridge for a meal it seems appropriate that the latest guest blog on this site is about football in that town. It’s by Neil Wolstenholme and Peter Hoctor. They are both Stalybridge natives and Stalybridge Celtic supporters. Neil is a former Celtic player and his father was a director of the club. Peter’s father was the club’s groundsman for many years. Today they’re talking about their new book on Stalybridge’s early football history. This piece talks of Stalybridge’s ‘other’ team Stalybridge Rovers. If you’re interested in football in Tameside or on the early history of the sport then get yourself a copy. It’s a fascinating book. Enjoy!

In April 1908 Stalybridge Rovers were due to play at Clitheroe. They never turned up. Instead, a telegram arrived with four words: ‘No money, no team.’

We were both born and bred in Stalybridge and we’re both Stalybridge Celtic fans. We had vaguely heard of Stalybridge Rovers, but we knew little about them until we started researching a book on Celtic. Most of their story had been forgotten or simply erased. Piece by piece, the old newspapers revealed a club which had won the Lancashire League, reached the first round proper of the FA Cup and twice tried to get into the Football League. That research became No Money, No Team: An early history of professional football in Stalybridge, 1880 to 1923.

So, who came before Rovers? Stalybridge St George’s, founded in 1883, with their headquarters at the Bull’s Head Inn and a pitch at Crookbottom. By 1887 they were the town’s leading club and members of the new Lancashire FA. Then, in January 1888, smallpox broke out in Stalybridge. Opponents refused to visit, fixtures were postponed for weeks, and the Saints faded away. Shades of 2020. By December 1888 the local paper was calling the new Stalybridge Rovers ‘late St George’s’.

Readers of this site will know Rovers’ world well. They played Ardwick, Newton Heath and Hurst, and in the 1890s they had a fierce rivalry with Ashton North End which could pull in 8,000 people. In October 1893 Newton Heath came to Crookbottom and the Clarion sent its writer, ‘the Bounder’, to kick off. He was not a fan: ‘There is no wetter place in England than Stalybridge.’ Having grown up there, we can’t really argue. In 1900 Rovers went to Hyde Road in the Manchester Senior Cup and lost 4-0, with legendary Billy Meredith scoring twice.

Some remarkable men wore the amber and black. Arthur Wharton, widely regarded as the world’s first black professional footballer, kept goal and captained the side. Herbert Chapman, later the very successful manager of Huddersfield Town and Arsenal, played for Rovers long before he changed how the game was played.

The good times rolled in 1899-1900 and 1900-01. Rovers knocked out Stockport County and Burslem Port Vale to reach the FA Cup first round proper, and 400 supporters caught a special train through the night to watch them lose 2-1 at Bristol City. The next season they won the Lancashire League on goal average. They applied to join the Football League in both years, gathering just one vote, then seven.

Within seven years of winning the league, Rovers were gone. How a champion club could fall so far, so fast, in a town which loved its football, is the story at the heart of the book.

Into the gap left by Rovers stepped a new club, Stalybridge Celtic, with a very different kind of backer. Herbert Rhodes was a local mill owner and magistrate, and with his support Celtic would go where Rovers never could, all the way into the Football League. Whether his money was enough, and whether Celtic learned from Rovers’ mistakes, is another matter.

This is a football story, but it is also a story about money. Without it, a club cannot compete and the reach for glory can end in disaster. Rovers were far from the last to learn that lesson. There have been numerous casualties. In 1962 Accrington Stanley resigned from the Football League in the middle of the season. In the 1980s Wolves slid from the First Division to the Fourth, while Bristol City survived only because eight players tore up their contracts. Aldershot and Maidstone United both went under in 1992. Leeds United borrowed to ‘live the dream’ and ended up in administration, Portsmouth won the FA Cup and then became the first Premier League club to go bust, and Glasgow Rangers were liquidated and restarted in Scotland’s fourth tier. More recently Bury were thrown out of the Football League and Macclesfield Town were wound up. The names and places may be different, but the pattern is one Rovers would have recognised.

What happened to Wharton after Stalybridge? Why did the League turn Rovers away? And how far was Herbert Rhodes prepared to go for Celtic? It’s all in No Money, No Team.

The book is available on Amazon: https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/106666370X.

Every penny of profit goes to the Stalybridge Celtic junior teams, so if you buy a copy you’re helping the next generation of Celtic players.

Neil Wolstenholme and Peter Hoctor are both Stalybridge natives and Celtic supporters. Neil is a former Celtic player and his father was a director of the club. Peter’s father was the club’s groundsman for many years.

Women’s Football in Manchester

With the latest edition of Manchester Corinthians: The Authorised History now at the designer, it feels like the perfect moment to reflect on an 11-year project into the history of women’s football in Greater Manchester.

When I began this project in 2015, there was no comprehensive, documented history of Manchester City’s early women’s team, nor of the pioneering Manchester Corinthians—two important teams that won leagues and competitions long before the establishment of the WSL. For years, many of the women who played for these teams felt excluded. Every time historians or the media repeated inaccurate assumptions, it felt as though those who played their part in building the foundations of the game were being deliberately erased from memory.

Over the past decade, this project has worked to change that by capturing the vital stories of players from the Corinthians, Nomads, All Stars, Dynamos, City, United, and beyond. The scale of this research includes:

• Over 50 personal interviews with Manchester Corinthians players alone.
• Approximately 90 interviews and chats with female players, spanning from the 1940s to recent icons like Jill Scott.
• Uncovering multiple founding Corinthians from the original 1948 squad.
• Unearthing a vibrant 1950s community of women’s football clubs spanning the north, south, west and east of the conurbation (complemented by Steve Bolton’s valuable research into Manchester Ladies).

I am incredibly proud that this research has brought these narratives into the public consciousness. The history of women’s football in Manchester is vastly better known today than it was eleven years ago.

However, there is still work to be done. Despite a decade of progress, historical misconceptions and origin myths continue to be repeated. As a passionate advocate for the Corinthians and their sister clubs, my goal is always to protect their legacy by focusing strictly on facts.

The biggest misconception is the claim that no other women’s teams existed in Manchester when the Corinthians were established. The facts tell a different story: the Corinthians were not the first post-WWII women’s team in the city, nor were they the only local side to tour abroad in the 1950s. Similarly, the role of these clubs in challenging the FA ban and establishing international, national, and regional competitions is still too often overlooked in mainstream spaces.

Correcting these narratives remains a priority through my ongoing books, talks, and lectures. Recently, this has continued down exciting avenues, including filming with UEFA, discussing theatrical projects for the stage, and holding serious developmental conversations with Manchester’s leading men’s clubs.

Looking back on the last eleven years, the journey has been profoundly rewarding. From creating the Corinthians’ blue plaque appeal and organising player reunions, to preserving the heritage of the early City Ladies, it has been an honour. Most of all, it has been a distinct pleasure to meet and engage with pioneering women across Europe, North America, and Australia who proudly played football in Manchester.

We have come a long way, but the storytelling continues. Watch this space!

On This Day Manchester City v Manchester United

On this day (10 November 1979) City beat United 2-0 at Maine Road with goals from Tony Henry and Mike Robinson. United players Kevin Moran and Mickey Thomas are seen on this photo with Polish World Cup star Kaziu Deyna. Video of the game can be seen here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rXExWITEtdI

Back in 2003 I wrote this profile of former Manchester City player and Polish World Cup star Deyna. He was such an important and unusual signing at the time he joined City in November 1978 that I feel this article is still appropriate and of interest to subscribers to my blog today.

Subscribe to get access

If you would like to read this in-depth article and all the others on this site (including the entire Manchester A Football History book) then please subscribe. It works out about £1.67 a month if you take out an annual subscription (£20 per year) or £3 a month if you’d like to sign up for a month at a time. Each subscriber gets full access to every article posted so far and all those posted throughout your subscription.

Manchester City Main Stand Burns Down

Only a few months after the King had visited Manchester City suffered a major blow when their Main Stand was destroyed by fire (6 November) 1920. Subscribers can read the story of this below (including the story of how City asked United if they could use Old Trafford temporarily which resulted in significant criticism of the Reds in national newspapers) but here’s a rare image that hasn’t been published in any Manchester City publication over the last century or so. It did appear in a contemporary newspaper. Notice the Ellison’s Rush Preventive turnstile that seems to have just about survived.

When City moved to Maine Road quite a few of these turnstiles were taken from Hyde Road and re-erected at Maine Road. In 2003 6 Ellisons turnstiles from the 1890s were still in place and in use during Maine Road’s final season.

In the years that followed the Hyde Rd fire there was a story that developed that the fire was the result of a Irish republican terrorist attack and that both Hyde Rd and Old Trafford were targets. The Old Trafford planned attack was foiled and has been written about in contemporary sources but Hyde Rd’s story cam much later. It doesn’t seem to be the case that the Hyde Rd fire was the result of terrorist activity – if there’s interest then maybe I’ll write the latest research on this in the coming months?

Subscribe to get access: Monthly

Read more of this content when you subscribe today. It costs £3 per month (cancel anytime) and monthly subscribers get access to everything posted since 1 October 2022 and throughout their subscription. Why not try for a month? There’s a special annual subscription for a discounted price and greater access (see below).

Subscribe to get access: Annual

Read more of this content when you subscribe today. It costs £20 per year (about £1.67) for this special, discounted annual rate. Annual subscribers get access to everything posted since December 2020 and throughout their subscription.

Back To The 1890s For The First League Manchester Derby

Today (3 November) is the anniversary of the first ever Manchester derby played in the Football League. The match between Manchester City and Newton Heath was played at City’s Hyde Road ground today in 1894. You can read the story of the game (with all the stats, background etc.) here:

The First Charity Shield Manchester Derby

Seventy years ago today (24 October 1956) the first Manchester Derby in the Charity Shield (now Community Shield) took place. Charity is much in evidence, as the Reds are allowed to replace ‘keeper Wood with their reserve David Gaskell when injury strikes. Attendance: 30,495; City 0 United 1.

The Champions beat the Cup holders under floodlights with a goal from local lad Dennis Violet.  United are the better side while City seem a little pedestrian.