The 1960s: Denis Law Signs

Today’s article on the 1960s is free for anyone to read and tells the story of Manchester City signing Denis Law back on 15 March 1960. There’s also film here of his debut and a great colour film of City and Law that season (see below). City manager Les McDowall had been after signing Denis Law for many, many months before he finally signed the Scottish striker for a British record fee of £55,000 the day before the transfer deadline on 15 March 1960.  It had been a tense negotiation.  Law himself had expected to join Arsenal to link up with his Scottish colleague Tommy Docherty, however, Huddersfield were adamant that they could not sell Law for anything less than £55,000.  

Ken Barnes welcomes Denis Law to Maine Road, 1960

It all came to a head at Leeds Road where Arsenal had sent coach Ron Greenwood to negotiate a good deal.  At the same time City, represented by Les McDowall and Chairman Alan Douglas, were keen to sign the 20 year old Scotsman.  The Gunners had only given Greenwood power to offer £25,000 plus David Herd, making a total of £50,000, whereas McDowall and Douglas were able to discuss the pros and cons of offering more.  The discussions and negotiations went on while Law himself was playing Table Tennis in the games room.  When the young player was summoned he quickly realised that his move to Arsenal was off and, after less than ten minutes, he agreed to join the Blues at a cost that was said to be three times his weight in gold.

Denis Law’s Manchester City debut 1960

Law made his debut a memorable one by scoring in the 4-3 defeat at Leeds on 19th March 1960.  You can view Law’s first goal for City here:

I think the commentary was added some time after and that the commentary was done in a studio over the top. The commentator (is it Stuart Hall?) mentions City’s kit as being old gold and black but colour film of kit from that season shows City wearing yellow and maroon – as can be seen in this wonderful film from that same year which includes Tottenham v City from about 5 minutes in:

https://player.bfi.org.uk/free/film/watch-saturday-fever-1961-online

Eleven days after Law’s debut he scored again as City defeated West Ham 3-1. He made one other appearance, away at Chelsea, before the player became the subject of his first controversy at the Club.  Law was selected to play for Scotland at Hampden Park on 9th April – the date of the vital home game with West Bromwich Albion – and the City management took the view that playing for your country was more important than playing for your club.  This angered many supporters, who realised that a Law-less City would struggle and that relegation was still a strong possibility.  The Blues were only two points above the relegation zone.

The controversy heightened when other clubs took a different view and refused to release players.  The City Board then felt justified in asking the League for a postponement, but the League refused.  In the programme for the game, the Board outlined their views and explained how the circumstance had occurred.  The article ended by stressing that the situation of club V Country cannot be allowed to continue.  

As expected, without Law the Blues were defeated 1-0.

You can find out more on Manchester City in the 1959-60 season by reading the following article on the season. This is available to subscribers.

Subscribe to get access

Read more of this content when you subscribe today. It costs £3 per month (cancel anytime) or sign up for a year at the discounted price of £20 per year (works out £1.67 per month). Subscribers access the 1000+ articles posted so far and the others scheduled during the life of your subscription.

Denis Law at City

Denis Law had such a wonderful footballing career, with so many periods deserving focus. Inevitably – and rightly – many will focus on his exploits with Manchester United and Scotland. Following his death I’d like to add to the tributes out there by highlighting a couple of periods of his career that may be being overlooked. It’s totally understandable, but today I’d like to highlight his Manchester City career. A career that saw him become a City legend. Not many manage to become idolised at both City and United in equal measure (Meredith & Kidd are the other prominent two I can think of) but Law managed it.

He was signed by City in March 1960 from Huddersfield Town for a record figure of £55,000 – £10,000 more than the previous British transfer record.  It was a bold move by Les McDowall but was clear proof that City were still a force to be reckoned with, particularly as they had managed to fight off the likes of Arsenal to sign the 20 year old.

Denis Law signs for City from Huddersfield

Law was a lethal finisher, and a genuine crowd pleaser.  His first goal for the Blues came during his debut match at Leeds United on 19th March 1960, although City were defeated by the odd goal in seven.  His second League game brought another goal as West Ham were defeated 3-1 at Maine Road on 30th March.  He ended the season with 7 appearances.

The following season he was top scorer with 19 League goals – 1 more than Joe Hayes – and again made the headlines with an amazing goalscoring feat in an abandoned cup tie.  On 28th January City were defeating Luton 6-2 with Law scoring all City’s goals, when the match was abandoned.  In the replay, Law again scored but this time City were defeated 3-1 in conditions which Law himself believed were worse than the original game.

In addition to his performances for City, Law was making a name for himself with his country.  He made 5 international appearances during his first two seasons at Maine Road, and was an obvious choice for his beloved Scotland. 

All the media interest which understandably focused on Law helped to make him known throughout the footballing world and, with City still struggling to find consistency during the early sixties, it was perhaps inevitable that he would move on.  In the end he was transferred to Italian side Torino for another record.  This time he became Britain’s first £100,000 footballer when the Italians paid City £110,000 for his signature in July 1961.

After a little over a year in Italy, Law returned to Manchester.  This time to help United.  In his first season there he helped the Reds avoid relegation, but regrettably City suffered as a consequence.  While at Old Trafford, Law found the success that had not seemed possible at Maine Road.

In July 1973 after becoming a legend with the Reds – please go and read everything you can about his career at Old Trafford – he was given a free transfer.  City manager Johnny Hart quickly made arrangements to sign the player, and on his second City debut he again scored (twice) as Birmingham were defeated 3-1.  Of the City side he joined in 1973 only Alan Oakes remained from his final City game in 1961, and the Blues were in an entirely different position.

The late sixties and early seventies had seen City achieve phenomenal success and eclipse Law’s United side, and so rather than join a poor, struggling side, law was now with a team of entertainers capable of tremendous success.  He had also joined a team renowned for its unpredictability!

Johnny Hart was replaced by disciplinarian Ron Saunders as manager, and the entire mood of the club changed.  Saunders seemed to be at odds with many of the club’s more senior professionals and his handling of the stars was often attacked.  For a while there were rumours of player power, especially when City started plummeting down the table.  Inevitably, Saunders was sacked and his replacement, Tony Book, managed to change the approach.  On the final day of the season, it was as a member of Book’s side that Law scored his final – and most memorable – League goal.

It was scored with his last kick in League football, and he often said it was the worst he had ever felt after scoring a goal. It wasn’t his last competitive goal in football or even for City – people often incorrectly claim it was but he played on into the 1974-75 season, scoring for City in a competitive game at the start of that season.

A page from Manchester A Football History by Gary James

City fans usually remember Denis Law more for that particular goal than for any other moment in his City career.  That goal was widely held responsible at the time of ‘sending Manchester United into the Second Division’.  In actual fact, the goal was irrelevant as United would have gone down in any case, but it has become a landmark goal and inevitably keeps the name of Law in the minds of Blues fans everywhere.  Law’s City career deserves to be remembered for much more.

Less than two months earlier he made his final appearance at Wembley as a member of City’s League Cup final team.  That game ended in a 2-1 defeat, but then it did take place during Ron Saunders’ period as manager.  Had the atmosphere of the club changed prior to Wembley then it’s possible Law’s illustrious career would have ended with a League Cup winners’ medal.

1974 League Cup final Tommy Booth, Francis Lee, Frank Munro, Denis Law.

Denis Law only managed three seasons with City in total, but in each of those seasons he did enough to make the headlines and become a member of City’s hall of fame.  During the mid 1970s The King’s Head pub at Crown Point, Denton became a shrine to football and its sign depicted “The King” Denis Law.  Although the nickname was awarded to him at Old Trafford, the pub sign depicted him in a City shirt – the team that first brought him to Manchester.  It should never be forgotten that Law is a hero to both Blues and Reds.  

Denis Law

I’ve just heard the sad news that yet another legendary footballer has passed away. Denis Law, who achieved major success in a glittering career for Huddersfield, Manchester City and Manchester United, has died aged 84.

I’ll post more on him over the coming days but, once again, following Bobby Kennedy and Tony Book this is yet another sad day for Manchester football.

There are plenty of articles mentioning Law on this site, here are those tagged with his name:

https://gjfootballarchive.com/tag/denis-law/page/2/

My thoughts are with Denis’s family and close friends.

The 1960s: 1959-1960 The Law Man

A new series of features on the 1960s starts with this subscriber article on Manchester City during the 1959-60 season. If you’d like to read this 1200 word article, plus all other articles on the site, then please subscribe (see below).

Subscribe to get access

Read more of this content when you subscribe today. It costs £3 per month (cancel anytime) or sign up for a year at the discounted price of £20 per year (works out £1.67 per month). Subscribers access the 1000+ articles posted so far and the others scheduled during the life of your subscription.

Starting Tomorrow: The 1960s

A new series of features on the 1960s starts tomorrow. It will focus predominantly on Manchester City during that decade. There will be a mixture of free articles and subscriber features. If you’d like to read everything then please subscribe (see below).

The series starts tomorrow with a 1200 word article on the 1959-60 season.

Les McDowall

Now that Pep Guardiola has managed his 500th Manchester City game (yes, I know he’s been ill and missed games but he’s still the manager when they occurred) here’s a brief look at the only manager ahead of his record at the club, Les McDowall (note: Les missed some games on scouting missions, so similar to Pep’s missed games?). Enjoy!

Les McDowall

June 1950 – May 1963

Previously:  Impressive wing-half for City during 40s.

Took Over From: Jock Thomson, who left in February 1950 as City headed towards relegation, but it is believed Wilf Wild with Fred Tilson filled the void between managers.

Inherited: Bert Trautmann, Roy Clarke, Joe Fagan & Johnny Hart.

Players Brought In Included: City’s talented forward Don Revie & inspirational captain Roy Paul.  Also Alex Harley & Peter Dobing.

Best Buy: For his role in the Revie Plan and long term commitment to the City cause – Ken Barnes.

Youngsters He Gave Debuts To: Joe Hayes, Dave Wagstaffe, John Benson, Neil Young, Alan Oakes & Glyn Pardoe.

First Game: Preston North End 2 City 4 (City scorers George Smith 2, Roy Clarke and Dennis Westcott), 19 August 1950, attendance 36,294.

High Points: Winning promotion during his first season; FA Cup finalists in 1955 & FA Cup winners in 1956 (and finishing fourth that season).

Coaches: Thirties stars Fred Tilson & Laurie Barnett.

Tactics: Became noted for tactical innovations such as the Revie Plan (although people assume this to be Revie’s idea the name came from the fact he was the key player; it had previously operated in the Reserves with Johnny Williamson in the role).  The Plan revolutionised City’s play and led to the mid-fifties success.   

Last Game: West Ham United 6 City 1 (City scorer Alan Oakes), 18 May 1963, attendance 16,602.

Season By Season Record:

League

1950-51 P 42            W 19   D 14    L 9      GF 89 GA 61 Pts 52             

1951-52 P 42            W 13   D 13    L 16    GF 58 GA 61 Pts 39             

1952-53 P 42            W 14   D 7      L 21   GF 72 GA 87 Pts 35             

1953-54 P 42            W 14   D 9      L 19    GF 62 GA 77 Pts 37             

1954-55 P 42            W 18   D 10    L 14    GF 76 GA 69 Pts 46             

1955-56 P 42            W 18   D 10    L 14    GF 82 GA 69 Pts 46             

1956-57 P 42            W 13   D 9      L 20    GF 78 GA 88 Pts 35             

1957-58 P 42            W 22   D 5      L 15    GF 104 GA 100 Pts 49       

1958-59 P 42            W 11   D 9      L 22    GF 64 GA 95 Pts 31            

1959-60 P 42            W 17   D 3      L 22    GF 78 GA 84 Pts 37            

1960-61 P 42            W 13   D 11    L 18    GF 79 GA 90 Pts 37            

1961-62 P 42            W 17   D 7      L 18    GF 78 GA 81 Pts 41            

1962-63 P 42            W 10   D 11    L 21    GF 58 GA 102 Pts 31

 2 points for a win

FA Cup

1950-51 P 1  W 0     D 0      L 1      GF 0   GA 2   Reached 3rd round

1951-52 P 2  W 0     D 1      L 1      GF 3   GA 6   Reached 3rd round

1952-53 P 3  W 1     D 1      L 1      GF 9   GA 6   Reached 4th round

1953-54 P 2  W 1     D 0      L 1      GF 5   GA 3   Reached 4th round

1954-55 P 6  W 5     D 0      L 1      GF 10 GA 4   Reached final

1955-56 P 7  W 6     D 1      L 0      GF 11 GA 4   FA Cup winners

1956-57 P 2  W 0     D 1      L 1      GF 5   GA 6   Reached 3rd round

1957-58 P 1  W 0     D 0      L 1      GF 1   GA 5   Reached 3rd round

1958-59 P 2  W 0     D 1      L 1      GF 3   GA 4   Reached 3rd round

1959-60 P 1  W 0     D 0      L 1      GF 1   GA 5   Reached 3rd round

1960-61 P 4  W 1     D 2      L 1      GF 4   GA 4   Reached 4th round

1961-62 P 2  W 1     D 0      L 1      GF 1   GA 2   Reached 4th round

1962-63 P 3  W 2     D 0      L 1      GF 3   GA 2   Reached 5th round

League Cup

1960-61 P 2  W 1     D 0      L 1      GF 3   GA 2   Reached 3rd round

1961-62 P 1  W 0     D 0      L 1      GF 2   GA 4   Reached 2nd round

1962-63 P 6  W 3     D 2      L 1      GF 10 GA 12 Reached 5th round

TOTAL (League & cup fixtures)

P591   W220  D127  L244   GF 1049        GA 1135

Trophies Won: FA Cup (1956) 

Other Competitive Fixtures: 1 Charity Shield game

They Said:  “Les McDowall was very much an old school manager – shirt & tie, office type.  You rarely saw him but when you did it was usually when he was unveiling one of his new tactical plans.  We had one where we played with 5 at the back and I had a number 7 shirt on.  He would probably have excelled in today’s game because he was absolutely driven with tactical formations.”  Defender Bobby Kennedy talking in 2005.

Followed By: George Poyser

After City: Became Oldham Athletic manager shortly after leaving City.  Died in August 1991 at the age of 78.

Chelsea v City

It’s Chelsea v Manchester City today. There are lots of features on this site about the two clubs such as this one talking about Alan Oakes’ debut:

Other features on City & Chelsea games can be read here:

https://gjfootballarchive.com/tag/chelsea/

MCFC Reserves 1958-59 and 1959-60

I’ve recently been asked about two players who were on Manchester City’s books, so thought I’d post a few details about them here, along with the Reserve line-ups for both 1958-59 and 1959-60. These make interesting reading, especially when attendances are checked.

I don’t have much on them but the players were Sand Wann and George Greenall. Wann joined City on 25/6/58 from Luncarty Juniors (Dave Ewing’s old team too!) and left City on 9/5/1960, joining St Mirren. George Greenall left City on 4/4/1960. My notes are not clear but George either went to Oldham or Southampton.

These images show the starting 11 for every MCFC Central League game in 1958-59 and 1959-60:

1958-59 Manchester City Reserves, Central League Starting 11
1959-60 Manchester City Reserves, Central League Starting 11

In 1959-60 George made 5 Central League appearances and Wann made 8. In 1958-59 Greenall played 2 and Wann 4.

Wann’s Central League games over both seasons were:

21/3/59 v Blackpool

11/4/59 v Barnsley

18/4/59 v Huddersfield

25/4/59 v Wolves

22/8/59 v Wolves

29/8/59 v Sheff Wed

31/8/59 v Chesterfield

5/8/59 v Aston Villa

19/3/60 v WBA

6/4/60 v Blackburn

15/4/60 v Bolton

23/4/60 v PNE

If you would like to support this website then why not subscribe or donate to keep it running? Details on how to subscribe appear lower down this page.

Oakes’ Debut Game

Today (14 November) is the anniversary of the first appearance for Manchester City’s first team of Alan Oakes. Oakes is City’s record appearance holder and that all important first competitive appearance came in a 1-1 draw with Chelsea back in 1959.

The City match stats can be read here:

https://bluemoon-mcfc.co.uk/History/Matches/Match.aspx?id=2318

The City scorer was Jack Dyson who had been out of action for two years with a broken leg and related complications. These two brief match reports suggest that Oakes had a good game.

Were you at this match? If so why not leave your memories below as comments. Thanks.

Derby Day 1959

Manchester City dominated the Manchester derby played on this day (19 September) in 1959. That day the Blues defeated the Reds 3-0 with an outstanding performance from Joe Hayes. Enjoy the match report here:

If you have enjoyed this then why not subscribe to the site to see all the other great content or make a donation to keep the site afloat. See below for details.